Battery Electric Bus vs Hybrid Electric Bus vs Hydrogen Fuel Cell Bus: Comparison
Today, in addition to traditional fuel-powered vehicles, buses powered entirely or primarily by alternative energy sources are gaining attention. There are three main types of new energy buses, classified by their power source: battery electric bus, plug-in hybrid electric bus, and hydrogen fuel cell bus.
Plug-in Hybrid Electric Buses
These buses combine a conventional fuel engine with electric components like motors, batteries, etc. They can charge their onboard energy storage devices from an external power source. Current operating models include two main types: gas-electric hybrids and diesel-electric hybrids. They can run in either electric-only mode or hybrid mode. In short-range trips, they operate in electric mode to save fuel and reduce emissions. For longer journeys, they switch to hybrid mode to extend range.
Hydrogen Fuel Cell Buses
Fuel cell buses generate electricity through a chemical reaction between hydrogen and oxygen, which powers the bus. Unlike conventional electric vehicles that draw power from grid-charged batteries, fuel cell buses use hydrogen as the main fuel source, supplied through hydrogen refueling stations similar to gas or charging stations. With high energy density, zero emissions, and quick refueling, they offer a promising alternative to traditional engines.
Battery Electric Buses
Battery electric buses rely entirely on electric power, using a motor, battery, and controller. They produce zero emissions, run quietly, and minimize vibration, making them a popular choice among new energy buses today. Battery electric buses are further categorized by their charging methods: fast-charging plug-in buses, standard-charging plug-in buses, and battery-swapping buses.
- Fast-Charging Battery Electric Bus: These buses have a charging rate of 3C or above. they utilize high-power batteries (such as lithium titanate, multi-composite lithium, or lithium manganese batteries) to achieve high charge and discharge rates, enabling fast charging.
- Standard Plug-in Battery Electric Bus: These buses have a charging rate below 3C.
- Battery-Swapping Electric Bus: These buses have removable batteries that can be quickly swapped with fully charged battery packs using automated or semi-automated equipment, providing a fast energy supply for the vehicle.
Comparative Analysis of Different Electric Bus Types
|
Bus Type
|
Pros
|
Cons
|
|---|---|---|
|
Fast-charging plug-in battery electric bus
|
Short charging time; optimizes space and infrastructure usage at bus depots; smaller batteries are required, making the bus lighter
|
Higher battery cost; increased power demand strains the grid and requires expensive infrastructure; energy costs can be high due to peak-hour charging
|
|
Standard-charging plug-in battery electric bus
|
Lower battery costs reduce financial pressure on fleet operators; can charge overnight during off-peak hours, cutting costs; slower charging is gentler on batteries and the grid
|
Requires more space at depots due to a lower station-to-bus ratio; additional staff may be needed for overnight charging; larger batteries are needed to meet daily demands, which adds weight
|
|
Battery-swapping electric bus
|
Fast battery swaps, usually 7-8 minutes for four battery packs, allow for efficient recharging; centrailized battery management extends battery lifespan
|
High battery costs; large space is needed to store charged and used batteries; charging multiple batteries at once can strain the grid
|
|
Plug-in hybrid electric bus
|
Easy to refuel with fuel or gas; economical due to reduced fuel consumption during start and acceleration
|
Higher maintenance due to breakdowns; limited fuel-saving benefits in practice
|
|
Hydrogen fuel cell bus
|
Zero emissions using renewable hydrogen fuel
|
Technology is still developing; building hydrogen refueling stations is costly
|
When comparing these options based on cost-efficiency, space needs, grid demand, operational flexibility, and durability, the standard-charging plug-in electric bus stands out for its balanced performance across most categories, though it does require more depot space.
Our Electrification Solution for Buses
Regardless of the alternative energy path chosen by bus manufacturers, we provide advanced solutions to power their project, supporting carbon reduction goals and promoting sustainable green transportation.
For the battery system for electric buses, we can provide complete and customized battery systems, incorporating battery packs, BMS with PDU, BTMS, and other components. We have designed the battery system for a Turkish bus manufacturer for their project. Learn more here: https://brogenevsolution.com/brogens-ev-battery-solution-powers-turkeys-battery-electric-bus-project/
For the e-powertrain system, we have the electric drive axles. They are designed to maximize vehicle layout efficiency, freeing up space for larger battery capacity and additional passenger room. They also enable a low-floor, single-step entry design, enhancing accessibility and passenger comfort.
Business inquiry: contact@brogenevsolution.com
Contact Us
Get in touch with us by sending us an email, using the Whatsapp number below, or filling in the form below. We usually reply within 2 business days.
Email: contact@brogenevsolution.com
Respond within 1 business day
Whatsapp: +8619352173376
Business hours: 9 am to 6 pm, GMT+8, Mon. to Fri.
LinkedIn channel
Follow us for regular updates >
YouTube channel
Ev systems introduction & industry insights >
